University of Oklahoma Removes Instructor Mel Curth After Samantha Fulnecky Bible-Based Essay Controversy

University of Oklahoma

University of Oklahoma Removes Graduate Instructor After Grading Dispute Over Bible-Based Essay

NORMAN, Okla. — The University of Oklahoma has removed a graduate teaching assistant from instructional duties following an investigation into claims that a student was unfairly graded for submitting a faith-based essay addressing gender roles.

The decision follows a high-profile dispute involving Samantha Fulnecky, a 20-year-old junior, who received a zero on a written assignment after citing her Christian beliefs to argue that there are only two genders.

The instructor, Mel Curth, a transgender graduate student who uses “she/they” pronouns, was teaching an undergraduate psychology course when the grading controversy erupted in late November. The university confirmed Monday that Curth has been stripped of teaching responsibilities after officials determined the grading was arbitrary.

“Based on an examination of the graduate teaching assistant’s own statements related to this matter, it was determined that the graduate teaching assistant was arbitrary in the grading of this specific paper,” the university said in a statement. “The graduate teaching assistant will no longer have instructional duties at the university.”

Assignment and Controversy

The assignment required students to write a 650-word response to an academic article analyzing whether conformity to gender norms affected popularity or bullying among middle school students.

Fulnecky’s response challenged the concept of multiple genders, arguing that gender is biologically determined and rooted in her Christian faith. While she did not formally cite the Bible, her essay referenced biblical beliefs and religious doctrine.

“I don’t believe there are more than two genders because that is how God made us,” Fulnecky wrote.

She further argued that societal acceptance of multiple genders harms children and contradicts her faith.

Curth responded by awarding Fulnecky a zero, stating that the essay failed to address the academic prompt and relied on “personal ideology” rather than “empirical evidence.” The instructor also described portions of the essay as “at times offensive.”

University Review and Outcome

Following the essay’s viral spread on social media and Fulnecky’s claim of religious discrimination, the university placed Curth on administrative leave and launched a formal review.

Earlier in December, the university announced that the failed assignment would not affect Fulnecky’s final grade. The subsequent investigation concluded that the grading decision lacked appropriate academic consistency.

The university emphasized that its decision was based on grading practices rather than the instructor’s personal identity or beliefs.

Broader Debate

The case has reignited national debate over academic freedom, religious expression, and classroom standards, particularly in discussions involving gender identity and faith-based viewpoints.

Supporters of Fulnecky argue students should not be penalized for expressing religious beliefs in academic settings, while others maintain that coursework must adhere to academic evidence and established scholarship.

The University of Oklahoma has not indicated whether additional policy changes or guidance for graduate instructors will follow.

FAQs: University of Oklahoma Removes Instructor After Grading Controversy

What happened at the University of Oklahoma?

The University of Oklahoma removed a graduate teaching assistant, Mel Curth, from instructional duties after determining that a student’s paper was graded arbitrarily following an internal review.

Who is the student involved in the controversy?

The student is Samantha Fulnecky, a 20-year-old junior at the University of Oklahoma who submitted a paper expressing Christian beliefs about gender roles.

What was the assignment about?

The assignment required students to write a 650-word response to an academic article analyzing whether conformity to gender norms affected popularity or bullying among middle school students.

Why did Fulnecky receive a failing grade initially?

Fulnecky received a zero after the instructor stated that her paper relied on personal ideology rather than empirical evidence and did not adequately address the academic prompt.

What did Fulnecky argue in her essay?

Fulnecky argued that she believes there are only two genders, stating that “that is how God made us,” and cited her Christian faith as the basis for her position.

Did Fulnecky formally cite the Bible in her paper?

According to reports, Fulnecky referenced Christian beliefs but did not formally cite the Bible in academic format.

Who is Mel Curth?

Mel Curth is a graduate student and teaching assistant in the psychology department who uses “she/they” pronouns and was responsible for grading the assignment.

Why was Curth removed from teaching duties?

The university stated that, after reviewing Curth’s own statements, it determined that the grading of Fulnecky’s paper was arbitrary, leading to Curth’s removal from instructional responsibilities.

Was Curth fired entirely from the university?

The university stated that Curth was stripped of instructional duties, but it did not publicly clarify whether she was fully terminated from all university roles.

Did the failing grade affect Fulnecky’s final course grade?

No. The university ruled earlier that the grade on the essay would not impact Fulnecky’s final grade in the course.

What role did public backlash play in the decision?

The incident gained national attention after Fulnecky’s essay went viral, prompting widespread public debate and leading the university to launch a formal investigation.

Did the university confirm religious discrimination?

The university did not explicitly label the incident as religious discrimination but concluded that the grading decision was not academically justified.

What justification did the instructor give for the failing grade?

Curth stated that the paper failed to engage with empirical research and contained assertions she described as “at times offensive.”

Did the university defend academic freedom?

The university emphasized academic standards while also stating that grading must be fair, objective, and non-arbitrary, regardless of viewpoint.

Has the university changed any policies as a result?

As of now, the university has not announced changes to grading policies or instructional guidelines related to the incident.

Why has this case drawn national attention?

The case touches on broader debates involving religious expression, academic freedom, gender ideology, and viewpoint discrimination in higher education.

Is the case considered resolved?

The university considers the matter resolved following Curth’s removal from teaching duties and the decision to protect Fulnecky’s course grade.

Comments

Tim Burchett Calls for Abolishing IRS as Trump Floats Ending Federal Income Tax

Tim Burchett Rep. Tim Burchett Calls for Abolishing IRS as Trump Floats Ending Federal Income Tax Republican Rep. Tim Burchett of Tennessee is calling for the abolition of the Internal Revenue Service, aligning himself with growing momentum inside the Republican Party as President Donald Trump openly suggests the United States could eliminate federal income taxes altogether. Burchett’s comments come after Trump told reporters Tuesday that Americans may soon “not even have income tax to pay,” arguing that tariff-driven revenue under his administration could make the federal income tax unnecessary. “At some point in the not too distant future you won’t even have income tax to pay,” Trump said following a cabinet meeting. “The revenue we’re collecting is so great — so enormous.” READ MORE: Dan Bongino Announces Resignation From FBI, Says He Is Returning to Media Trump Pushes Tariff-Based Revenue Model Trump has repeatedly endorsed replacing income taxes with tariffs, marking his mo...

Joni Ernst Moves to Expose Federal Bureaucracy With New Public Database Proposal

Joni Ernst BREAKING: Sen. Joni Ernst Moves to Expose Federal Bureaucracy With New Public Database Proposal WASHINGTON, D.C. — Republican Senator Joni Ernst of Iowa announced new legislation aimed at lifting the veil on the federal workforce by creating a public database of government employees , including names, salaries, job duties, and agency assignments. The proposal, formally titled the Where’s the Workforce At Listed by Duties and Office (Where’s WALDO) Act , would require the U.S. Office of Personnel Management (OPM) to publish a comprehensive directory of federal employees currently paid with taxpayer funds. Targeting a Growing and Costly Federal Workforce Ernst’s legislation follows a recent report by fiscal watchdog group Open The Books , which found that the federal bureaucracy has grown larger, wealthier, and more opaque since 2020. According to the report, 383,000 federal employees across 56 agencies had their names redacted from publicly available payroll data, despit...

Federal Civil Rights Division Sues DC, Georgia, Illinois, and Wisconsin Over Failure to Produce Voter Rolls

Photo credit: Gage Skidmore/CC BY-SA 2.0, via Flickr Justice Department Files Lawsuits Against Four States Over Voter Roll Access The U.S. Department of Justice has filed federal lawsuits against four jurisdictions—Washington, D.C., Georgia, Illinois, and Wisconsin—alleging failure to comply with federal requests for full voter registration records. The legal action was announced by the Justice Department’s Civil Rights Division as part of a broader nationwide effort to enforce federal election laws and ensure voter list transparency. According to the department, the lawsuits stem from the jurisdictions’ refusal or failure to provide complete statewide voter registration lists, despite formal requests made under federal law. The filings bring the total number of voter-roll-related enforcement actions taken by the Justice Department to 22 nationwide. READ MORE: Federal Civil Rights Investigation Launched Into Boston Housing Program Under Boston Mayor Michelle Wu At th...

Federal Civil Rights Investigation Launched Into Boston Housing Program Under Boston Mayor Michelle Wu

Photo credit: Gage Skidmore/CC BY-SA 2.0, via Flickr Federal Civil Rights Investigation Launched Into Boston Housing Program Under Mayor Michelle Wu BOSTON — The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) has opened a civil rights investigation into Boston Mayor Michelle Wu’s housing policies, raising questions about whether the city’s affordable housing programs unlawfully prioritize applicants based on race. HUD officials confirmed Thursday that the probe will examine Boston initiatives that allegedly favor Black and Latino residents in access to affordable housing. The investigation marks the first racial discrimination inquiry into a city’s housing practices under the Civil Rights Act initiated during President Donald Trump’s current administration. Assistant Attorney General Harmeet Dhillon confirmed the investigation publicly, signaling that federal authorities are scrutinizing whether Boston’s policies violate constitutional and civil rights protecti...

Dan Bongino Announces Resignation From FBI, Says He Is Returning to Media

FBI Deputy Director Dan Bongino Dan Bongino Announces Resignation From FBI, Says He Is Returning to Media FBI's Deputy Director Dan Bongino, a prominent conservative media figure and former Secret Service agent, has announced that he will resign from his position at the FBI in January, bringing an end to a high-profile and controversial chapter of public service. Bongino confirmed his departure in a statement, thanking President Donald Trump, Attorney General Pam Bondi, and FBI Director Kash Patel for the opportunity to serve. He emphasized that his decision was driven by family priorities after an intense period of work inside the bureau. “I will be leaving my position with the FBI in January,” Bongino said. “I want to thank President Trump, AG Bondi, and Director Patel for the opportunity to serve with purpose. Most importantly, I want to thank you, my fellow Americans, for the privilege to serve you.” Leaving Media Empire to Take on FBI Reform Before joining the FBI, Bongino wa...

DOJ Sues Minneapolis Public Schools Over Alleged Race-Based Teacher Hiring Practices

Photo credit: Gage Skidmore/CC BY-SA 2.0, via Flickr DOJ Sues Minneapolis Public Schools Over Alleged Race-Based Teacher Hiring Practices MINNEAPOLIS, Minn. — The U.S. Department of Justice has filed a federal lawsuit against Minneapolis Public Schools (MPS) , alleging that the district engaged in race-based discrimination in employment decisions , marking a significant escalation in the Trump administration’s push against diversity-focused hiring and retention programs. The lawsuit was announced by Assistant Attorney General Harmeet Dhillon , who leads the DOJ’s Civil Rights Division. The complaint alleges that MPS violated federal civil rights law by prioritizing certain racial groups in teacher employment decisions, including programs that reportedly favored “Black Men Teach Fellows” and other populations identified as underrepresented. READ MORE: Harmeet Dhillon Investigates Kent State Over Shocking Racial Segregation in A Cappella Auditions DOJ Claims Race-Based...

How to Watch Trump Rally in North Carolina: Time, Live Stream for GOP Event

Donald Trump Former President Donald Trump will be hitting the campaign trail in North Carolina today. He'll be at the Aero Center at ILM airport in the Wilmington area to hold a "Save America Trump" rally in support of the Republican candidates. Theodore Paul Budd is an American businessman and politician who has served as the U.S. representative for North Carolina's 13th congressional district since 2017. He is running for one of North Carolina's seats in the United States Senate. We will have the latest here on air as well as through streaming on our website, Politicalhub.co.in The "Save America" rally will be held in the Aero Center at Wilmington International Airport, which is located at 1830 Flightline Road, south of Highway U.S. 117, which connects to Interstate 40 East. It is north of U.S. Route 74. Ted Budd, Bo Hines, Lt. Gov. Mark Robinson, Rep. David Rouzer, Michael Whatley, and many other North Carolina Republicans are expected to spe...

South Carolina Supreme Court Hands Trump Administration Major Victory on Voter Roll Oversight

Photo credit: Gage Skidmore/CC BY-SA 2.0, via Flickr South Carolina Supreme Court Ruling Clears Path for Federal Review of State Voter Rolls COLUMBIA, S.C. — The South Carolina Supreme Court has delivered a major legal victory to former President Donald Trump’s Justice Department , allowing federal officials to access and review the state’s voter rolls as part of a broader nationwide effort to identify allegedly ineligible voters. The ruling permits the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) to move forward with efforts to examine and potentially require updates to South Carolina’s voter registration lists. The decision comes amid an aggressive push by the Trump administration to increase federal oversight of state election data, a responsibility traditionally reserved for states under the U.S. Constitution. Assistant Attorney General Harmeet Dhillon , who leads the DOJ’s Civil Rights Division, said the department is acting under its statutory authority to enforce federal voti...

Marco Rubio Holds Marathon Press Conference, Fields Questions for Over Two Hours

Marco Rubio Secretary of State Marco Rubio Holds Marathon Press Conference, Fields Questions for Over Two Hours WASHINGTON, D.C. — December 19, 2025 — Secretary of State Marco Rubio on Thursday held one of the longest press conferences of any U.S. Secretary of State in recent history, taking questions from nearly 50 journalists over the course of more than two hours on a wide range of domestic and international issues. The extended briefing took place in the State Department Press Briefing Room , where Rubio emphasized openness, accessibility, and a recalibration of U.S. foreign policy under the Trump administration . Reporters posed dozens of questions—often with multiple follow-ups—covering global security, diplomacy, and the administration’s foreign policy priorities. Rubio began his remarks by thanking members of the press and signaling his intent to prioritize transparency. “I wanted to start — I’m going to be very brief because I just want to get to as many questions as...

Tim Burchett Calls for U.S. Exit From NATO, Citing Cost and Constitutional Concerns

Tim Burchett BREAKING: Rep. Tim Burchett Calls for U.S. Exit From NATO, Citing Cost and Constitutional Concerns WASHINGTON, D.C. — Rep. Tim Burchett (R-TN) has called for the United States to withdraw from the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO), arguing that the alliance has outlived its original purpose and continues to impose enormous financial and military burdens on American taxpayers. “NATO was created to counter the Soviet Union, which collapsed over thirty years ago,” Burchett said. “Since then, U.S. participation has cost taxpayers trillions of dollars and continues to risk U.S. involvement in foreign wars.” Burchett framed his argument around constitutional principles, warning against what he described as permanent foreign entanglements. “Our Constitution did not authorize permanent foreign entanglements, something our Founding Fathers explicitly warned us against,” he said. “America should not be the world’s security blanket — especially when wealthy countries ...

Ad